Right, well keeping quiet about the truth does not make it fiction. While watching the news reports of the G20 riots in Toronto, I tried very hard to keep calm and objective. But the truth of the matter is that I’m pissed off.
As Mayor David Miller intelligently mentioned (my first indication the situation was going to hell), Toronto regularly sees protests. The difference is that violent protests are almost unheard of, it just isn’t the way we do things. Mayor Miller then went on to voice a belief that the violent instigators were visitors with an agenda for this sort of thing. I can’t say as to whether I believe that any politician could nail 2 facts in a single statement, but it is understandable to hope that this is not the Canadian way.
The part that pisses me off is simple – the use of violence and destruction. Canadians can bitch and moan with the best of them, we might even be the best complainers in the world. The difference is that we don’t always have to break things or hurt people in the process. Maybe it’s the patience that Canadian winter teaches or we just can’t get as worked up as other nations, but our protests are usually pretty calm.
In fact, it is not uncommon for protests to be conducted by paid students. That’s right, professional protesters. It makes sense if you think about it; instead of taking the day (or more if incarcerated) off work, an activist could hire 2-3 students to protest by proxy. The protest becomes a smooth advertisement production ready for the news without emotional escalation. In essence, many protests become a type of improvised social theatre. And you thought Smart Mobs were a new thing!
But this weekend was something totally different. People carrying pick-axes and burning police cruisers. I’ll not shed a tear for the insurance companies that have to replace some windows, but the destruction put people out of work, embarrassed Canada just before its birthday, and made every protester a voiceless twit.
When a protest digresses into violence, the method speaks louder than the message. Those 1% of protesters that resorted to violence muted the voices of the 99% who just wanted to be heard. Additionally, in this world of constant, live news coverage, the blame cannot be easily shifted to the police. I watched protesters instigate incident after incident with the police that consistently acted within reason.
If 30 police officers ask you to move out of the way, then move out of the way. Starting a fight makes you an idiot, not a hero. I am not against civil disobedience; I write blog posts designed to get people thinking and challenge paradigms in a peaceful way. If your cause requires you to protest, be a nuisance but never resort to violence. Remember that Mohandas Gandhi proved to be so great a nuisance to Britain that he made significant changes for his people without ever condoning violence. All you will accomplish through violence is muting your opinion.
Go ahead and argue with me but don’t come looking for a fight.